Table of Contents
Materials You has been round for just a few years now, and with Android 14 proper across the nook, it is easy to take this incredible characteristic with no consideration. Nonetheless, regardless of the enhancements made in Android 13, I’m nonetheless resigned to sending apps to my display of disgrace two years after the characteristic debuted. It is an issue I anticipate to persist on all the things from Pixel telephones to finances Android tablets.
Right here it’s, my display of disgrace
Meet my display of disgrace. That is the place all my apps that do not help Materials You’s themed icons stay. It is an unsightly, uninspiring place that does not have to exist.
The discharge of Android 12 was a godsend to folks like me, who at all times needed to have a gorgeous custom-made telephone however received bored negotiating with icon packs and even the very best Android launchers. A unified, dynamic theme that may routinely convey (nearly) all of my apps into visible symmetry? Sure, please! Nonetheless, the dearth of dynamic icon theme help for third-party apps has highlighted the obvious concern with Materials You.
Nonetheless, the long run might maintain the answer. A characteristic noticed earlier this 12 months in Android 13 QPR2 Beta 2 would routinely create a monochrome model of each app icon in your telephone, which might then be used for dynamic icon theming. Nonetheless, it is nonetheless an experimental characteristic, and there is no assure we’ll see a secure launch. Till then, the display of disgrace stays.
What went improper with Materials You
The purpose of Materials You was to unify your Android telephone, bringing all the things collectively right into a harmonious complete. Dynamic theming means you may by no means take a look at the identical mixture of colours twice whereas fonts and shapes meld collectively right into a seamless digital tapestry. However when you exit the fastidiously managed environments of Google’s apps, a muddle of discordant colours involves the fore.
Whereas there’s nothing Google can do concerning the apps moreover encouraging builders to make use of Materials You, Android 13 brings dynamic icon theming to all apps, which might theoretically remedy this downside in your homescreen. But it surely will not.
Android 13’s dynamic icon theming partially solves this downside, however until Google finds a technique to drive it on icons seamlessly, the issue will not go away. It is because it depends on app builders, and whereas many hip and contemporary apps are keen to make the adjustments, many extra will not.
You could discover within the above screenshots that Sync, a third-party Reddit app, has a themed icon. Sync has absolutely embraced the Materials You type, comfortably current alongside official Google apps.
Nonetheless, Sync’s adherence to Google’s design merely highlights the difficulty. Fashionable apps like Sync and Inware is likely to be all-in on Google’s design language, however who will observe? A few of my apps are historic. The day Nationwide Rail provides Materials You help is when Google does not leak all the things forward of an official reveal date. Builders have to present a monochromatic model of their app icon to affix within the theming enjoyable. It is further work that underfunded improvement groups might not have the time for.
Third-party icon packs vs. themed icons
The answer is likely to be putting in one of many prime third-party icon packs. Many choices can be found, which basically do the identical factor because the Materials You themed icons however with extra app help.
The essential distinction between third-party icon packs and themed icons is how the work is distributed. Making a unified expertise is a precedence for third-party launchers, not an non-compulsory further. However this comes with a few disadvantages. First, in the event you’re a fan of Materials You, you will not expertise the harmonious themes which can be its key promoting level. Second, builders don’t have any say in how their app icons will look.
It is simple to see what app icons have Materials You potential and which do not.
By placing the work within the fingers of the builders, Google ensures builders can create an app that matches the Materials You theme whereas retaining management over how their app icon appears. Nonetheless, not each improvement crew will view this as a precedence. And whereas the present type is for minimalistic icons, what about video games that depend on busy icons or firms that do not wish to lose their model colours?
The way forward for app icon theming
Google’s try at encouraging app icon uniformity has additionally vastly lowered the customization out there to the consumer. As an example, font and icon customization had been dropped for Android 12. You probably have too many apps in your homescreen, the themed icons grow to be an incongruent blur of daring traces and pastel shades. It is a neat concept in the event you suppose an IKEA showroom is the height of design. Nonetheless, for many who want to have their telephone really feel prefer it’s completely theirs, Materials You does not ship. At the least not but.
Think about a giant white app icon on the Google Pixel Fold’s in any other case attractive homescreen.
The Google Pixel Fold, which was revealed alongside the Google PIxel 7a and plenty of different merchandise at Google I/O 2023. The brand new foldable exhibits off a giant show with Materials You entrance and middle. However I can not assist however suppose that with a display that huge, Google must take a step past monochrome icons to create a really progressive design language.