Google bans Downloader app for one thing that Chrome additionally does


Google has suspended a preferred app from the Play Retailer as a result of it will possibly load a pirate web site, which Google Chrome or another net browser can do as nicely. The app named Downloader was eliminated following a Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) criticism from a gaggle of Israeli TV corporations.

Play Retailer suspended the Downloader app as a result of it will possibly load a selected web site

Downloader is a free app for Android TV and Amazon Fireplace TV units. It’s a utility app that gives a built-in net browser mixed with a file supervisor. It lets customers “simply obtain information from the web onto their gadget”. You’ll be able to manually enter a URL or sideload the online browser plugin to obtain information from web sites. The app has been round for about seven years now, accumulating greater than 50 million installs throughout the 2 platforms.

However Google lately suspended Downloader from the Play Retailer citing a DMCA criticism that states that the app “permits customers to view the notorious copyright infringing web site often known as SDAROT” (by way of). The developer of the app Elias Saba cites took to Twitter and his weblog to share the unlucky information. In accordance with Saba, the DMCA criticism was served by a legislation agency on behalf of a number of Israeli TV firms. These embody Sure TV and Sizzling TV.

The first criticism is that the app can load the aforementioned pirate web site, which already has everlasting injunctions issued towards it by two Israeli courts and a US federal court docket (issued by a US District Court docket decide in New York in April 2022). However as mentioned earlier than, this isn’t one thing that solely Downloader can do. Any net browser permits customers to load any energetic web site that isn’t blocked by their web supplier or native authorities.

Saba states that he has no affiliation with the web site in query or its operator. “Any rational individual would agree you could’t presumably blame an online browser for the pirated content material that exists on the web,” Saba vented out his frustration in his weblog submit. “My app by no means directs customers to any particular web site apart from my very own [www.aftvnews.com, which is the browser’s default homepage].”

Google rejected the developer’s attraction

Shortly after Google suspended Downloader from the Play Retailer, Saba filed appeals via the Google Play Console and the corporate’s DMCA counter notification kind. Nevertheless, the Google Play Console attraction was rejected inside about an hour. “We’ve reviewed your attraction request however we’re nonetheless unable to reinstate your app,” the rejection discover mentioned.

In the meantime, in response to Saba’s DMCA counter, Google mentioned that it’s giving the TV corporations ten days to file “both an motion that seeks a court docket order to restrain the allegedly infringing exercise or a declare of infringement with the US Copyright Workplace Copyright Claims Board”. In the event that they don’t go to court docket, Downloader needs to be again within the Play Retailer in per week or so.

Nonetheless, as Saba says, “It’s a ridiculous declare and an abuse of the DMCA”. The app could also be again, however the developer has already misplaced a variety of present customers or potential new customers. The app reportedly had 36 p.c fewer customers per week after Google suspended it. “I’ve misplaced it doesn’t matter what,” the creator of the Downloader app mentioned. The app continues to be accessible on the Amazon app retailer for Fireplace TVs or as an APK file from the official web site.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *